Using local vernacular media to share knowledge and engage policy
By Shibaji Bose a knowledge translator in climate change and health systems research and a member of the Translating Evidence to Action Thematic Working Group.
The media have a fundamental role to play when it comes to communicating research and evidence to a broader audience. With this in mind, engagement of mainstream Indian media at the national and regional levels were very important when it came to sharing the Sundarbans Health Watch report. But this did not address the challenge of how to reach the policy implementers at the grassroots.
The challenge was to specifically reach the local implementers and local self-government functionaries (panchayat representatives) of The Indian Sundarbans who play a very crucial role in implementing policies and could use these research findings to inform their decisions.
Why local print media?
As an overwhelming percentage of the island population of the Sundarbans read Bengali (the local language) newspapers, English newspapers were not an option. Some of the Bengali mainstream newspapers do reach the islanders but mostly the landlocked portion of the archipelago or the prominent towns in the islands. So, we needed a vehicle to reach more people. And it had to be a credible source.
During our research, we found out that there is a vibrant local print media which has a dedicated readership as they publish local news like news on innovations in agriculture or regional weather forecasts to which the population can readily relate. And more importantly, they reach the remotest islands, which is often outside the reach of the major newspapers.
But while scanning the newspapers we found that most of the print houses either have never used research or have very negligible capacity to write on research evidence, most of which are published in English.
Supporting local media to use and translate research
We talked to the editors and proprietors of the local print media and to local journalists’ associations about the importance of sharing the findings. We planned and organized a series of workshops on health policy, contextual determinants of health, and where to get the latest figures on the healthcare of the local districts and blocks.
We came with a less technical, vernacular version of our report to help understand the evidence. During the workshop, it was easy for the journalists to contextualize the evidence and connect to their readership because they are all from the Sundarbans archipelago themselves. The results were more than we expected:
The members of the Future Health Systems research team were invited to write regular columns on their experiences and what the findings mean to the local community.
News on health and health needs of the community, especially children, increased 2.5 times over a period of an entire year (evidence-informed by scanning the newspapers). The representatives of the local self-governments (panchayats) and the medical staff at the Kawkdwip and Namkhana blocks, including the doctors, welcomed the scientific evidence, and various health and family welfare committees requested that the research team present the findings to their staff directly.
By highlighting the efforts of the doctors who came from the cities to these remote islands, some of which lack the basic amenities, the community’s appreciation of the commitment of these doctors began to be reflected in the doctor-patient relationship.
The community became aware of the necessary steps to be taken to safeguard the health of the children particularly in the aftermath of climate shocks like flooding and inundation.
The mainstream newspapers also started picking up the news from their local counterparts and it resulted in the publishing of more health news from Sundarbans in the Kolkata based newspapers.
What did we learn?
Our experience highlights how the local media embedded in social, economic and political dynamics of their community have the capability to highlight gaps in healthcare service delivery and to advocate for a community-centered health system. In addition, the community has trust in local media as a reliable voice for expressing their health demand to relevant policymakers.
On the flipside, policymakers at district and local level can also make the most of the positive engagement with local media to generate awareness, particularly for those living in the remotest areas.
We believe that working with the local media has to be part of any strategy to achieve Universal Health Coverage. Underpinning that, it is vital when it comes to fostering positive change – from knowledge sharing between researchers and the community, visibility or recognition, to changes in attitudes and behaviors that lead to the uptake of health systems research.
Photo credit – Shibaji Bose